Only a Machine-Readable Date Survived a Same-Search Test
Underneath compared cited and passed-over pages on the same AI Overview. Position still came first. One on-page feature held up.
Direct answer
Underneath's 8 October 2026 update says that, on the same search, only a machine-readable date still predicted an AI Overview citation after a correction for 14 tests: +7.9 points, with a 95 percent interval from 2.9 to 12.9.
Underneath updated its AI Overview citation study on 8 October 2026. Version 1.1 looks at 486 US searches that showed an AI Overview. For each search it fetched the pages ranking in the top 10 and compared the pages the overview cited with the pages it passed over on the same results page. The comparison is against competitors on that search, not against the web in general. Fourteen page features were entered together.
Ranking position still came first. The update says 41.7 percent of pages ranking 1 to 3 were cited, against 20.1 percent at positions 7 to 10. Within the same search, position accounted for 6.1 percent of the variation in which pages were cited. The 14 page features added 2.5 points more. The update says 91.4 percent of the variation was left unexplained by anything measured.
After a correction for testing 14 features at once, one on-page feature remained: a machine-readable date, at +7.9 points, with a 95 percent interval from 2.9 to 12.9. That association is confined to informational searches, at +17.8 points, against +1.0 on commercial and transactional searches. Article schema shows the same split, +10.9 against +0.1. Organization schema, BreadcrumbList schema, and HTML tables showed no meaningful association with being cited. Their intervals sit inside plus or minus 5 points. Question-form headings, which had been +9.6 points in version 1.0, fell to +3.5, with an interval from -0.3 to 7.1.
Citation is not the same as wording
The update says only 21.0 percent of cited pages were the answer's first source. In 62.2 percent of cited pages, no passage that cites the page had at least 80 percent of its content words on the page. Pages with a table were 14.7 points more likely to have their passages absorbed, even though tables did nothing for the citation itself.
Source: Underneath, 3,096 AI Overview pages.
FAQ
- Did question headings still matter?
- The update says question-form headings fell to +3.5 points, with an interval from -0.3 to 7.1, so they are no longer distinguishable from zero.
- Does a citation mean the page was quoted?
- The update says only 21.0 percent of cited pages were the answer's first source, and 62.2 percent had no citing passage with at least 80 percent of its content words on the page.